18 Best Pizza Places in Green Bay, WI [2023 Updated]

Literally speaking, pizza is a divisive subject in Green Bay. It’s more like politics and religion—it sparks debates.

For instance, a question was recently posted on Reddit: Who has the best pizza in Green Bay? Pizza preferences seemed to vary widely.

So, I’ll dole out the 18 best pizza places in Green Bay based on Redditers’ suggestions. This list also hinged on genuine user reviews from Google, Yelp, and TripAdvisor, giving you a clear picture of the user experience.

Also, check out their websites because some shops may have closed due to COVID-19. Now let’s hit the ground running!

1. Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

• Address: 2161 S Oneida St., Green Bay, WI 54304
• Phone Number: (920) 499-6644

Sammy’s is a Pizza & Italian restaurant whose operations began in 1958. This shop is a clear fan favorite, especially if positive reviews from TripAdvisor and Yelp are anything to go by.

The pizzeria uses family recipes for its pizza dough, sauce, and sausage. They also take advantage of fresh ingredients to complement their pie.

Sammy’s Pizza has an edge over others in terms of cheese quality. It gets liquidy and melty with generous amounts of cheese. And the flavor? Mmm – umami!

Lastly, this pizza place proudly offers homemade soup and salads, freshly baked sandwiches with chips, and desserts! Meatballs and four pasta sauces are also on offer.

 

2. Cranky Pat’s Pizza

• Address: 709 Bellevue St., Green Bay, WI 54302
• Phone Number: (920) 468-7777

Cranky Pat’s has been feeding Fox Valley folks since 1955. It’s obvious: this award-winning pizza place has stood the test of time.

Pat Earle’s recipe is nothing but impressive. When you bite into Cranky Pat’s thin-crust pizza, you can immediately feel the freshness of the ingredients.

Here, chefs pile copious amounts of cheese over Pat’s sauce. With just one bite, you can tell the deliciousness of this pizza is lush and out of this world!

And yes, most of the Redditers cited the toppings. For most, cheese and mushrooms were a favorite. You’ll also get a salad bar with fresh greens at every Cranky Pat’s Pizza shop.

 

3. Glass Nickel Pizza

• Address: 416 Dousman St., Green Bay, WI 54303
• Phone Number: (920) 490-1000

This place is nothing short of a foodie haven. Glass Nickel has been serving (and delivering!) award-winning pies for 22 years.

The dough and sauce are made fresh in-house daily at Glass Nickel Pizza. Fresh veggies, quality meats, and ingredients; are used to ensure the best pie.

Do you have a late-night craving for incredible pizza? Worry not! This pizza place is closed late into the night to meet your needs. It may be ideal for when you throw parties at night!

Furthermore, Glass Nickel Pizza got angels for staff. Those guys and gals are really awesome. And they’re always careful not to screw up your order.

 

4. Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream

• Address: 1675 E Mason St., Green Bay, WI 54302
• Phone Number: (920) 465-0690

Happy Joe’s is mainly known for its Taco Pizza. It’s universal knowledge among enthusiasts that taco pizza is terrific.

If you go to Happy Joe’s, don’t end your pizza exploration before tasting the pie with some Sauer Kraut.

Here’s a hint: it would be best to visit during a Happy Joe’s buffet night to try the variety. This pizza place serves guests many signature pizzas.

You’ll also find creative sandwiches, creamy ice cream, and delicious pasta day by day. And if you need something different, try Happy Joe’s Pan Crust. There’s no way your family will reject this!

 

5. Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge

• Address: 13201 Velp Ave., Green Bay, WI 54313
• Phone Number: (920) 544-9379

Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge sits at a 112-year-old chapel in vintage downtown Suamico. You’ll come across varieties of pizza, including Vegan and Gluten-Free ones.

In fact, this pizza shop’s special diets are Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan, and Gluten-Free Options. If you want New York-style crust, Rustique Pizzeria has got you covered.

Their thin-crust pizzas come with a savory combination of fresh toppings. Honestly, where else will you find another pizza as good as this?

And as if it’s not enough, the cozy lounging area at Rustique is very inviting. It’s best for your next date night, business dinner, or family outing.

 

6. Back Nine Pizza

• Address: 1671 Hoffman Rd #50, Green Bay, WI
• Phone Number: (920) 632-2034

Are you searching for gluten-free pizza? Look no further than Back Nine Pizza. Here, the crust matters more than anything.

Back Nine Pizza’s crust is crisp, light, and airy. You should try it when you pass by Hoffman and see how praiseworthy it is!

What happens is that their pizza tends to melt in your mouth. Some customers even refer to it as “life-changing.”

At Back Nine Pizza, individual slices, medium and large pizzas are always available for dine-in or carry-out.

What’s more, is that the shop offers Curbside pickup. But you’ll need to call ahead of time to make such arrangements.

 

7. Old Chicago Pizza

• Address: 2495 South Oneida St., Green Bay, WI 54304
• Phone Number: (920) 884-1112

 

Chicago-style deep-dish pizza has been a beloved treat of locals and visitors alike. The Old Chicago Pizza welcomes you to enjoy this pie at the terrific dine-in setting.

But if you’re not a fan of thick-walled pies, Chicago Pizza offers a tavern-style thin crust. It is round in shape, as opposed to Detroit’s deep dish.

The crust is airy and bakes in a square pan. Old Chicago Pizza crust options include a Hand-Tossed Ale Crust, providing a slight ale flavor.

There’s also a Gluten-Free Crust for those who want this option. Perhaps the most important thing about the Old Chicago Pizza is that any pizza options can turn into calzones – if need be!

 

8. Scott’s Subs

• Address: 810 S Huron Rd, Green Bay, WI 54311
• Phone Number: (920)489-2050

Scott’s Subs deals in an array of brick oven-style pizzas polished with classic and creative toppings. The crust was thin and crispy.

At Scott’s Subs, the dough is made in-house with premium, high-gluten flour, proofed in coolers for several days. Ensuing, it produces a crispy crust on the outside and chewy in the middle.

This pizza parlor makes pizzas, salads, and ice cream using fresh, never frozen ingredients. Their pasta is also homemade, utilizing a pasta machine imported from Italy.

 

9. Pizza Ranch

• Address: 2206 Main St, Green Bay
• Phone Number: (920) 468-3555

Pizza Ranch restaurant may be the perfect choice for those seeking more than just pizza at a buffet. You can choose your favorite pizza, and then the staff will serve it at your table.

They also offer chicken dinners, traditional wings, and hearty sides. And oh! Don’t forget the giant chocolate chip cookie on the dessert tab.

But aside from the great food, Pizza Ranch supports the community by holding fundraising events. Proceeds go to children so they can eat pizza every Tuesday – for free!

 

10. Gallagher’s Pizza

• Address:1651 S Webster Ave, Green Bay, WI 54301
• Phone Number: (920) 321-5555

Gallagher’s is famous for its enormous pizza, which is incredibly delicious. It features the marrying flavors of Italy with the heart of the Irish.

And with some addition of Chicago flare, the result is the authentic Gallagher’s Pizza. Not only is the pie amazing, but it also features some bacon, mac, and cheese. And their breadstick, though? They’re deep-fried and not baked.

Aside from the food, they also offer a dependable delivery for a lazy night at home. And yes! No need to visit Webster Ave to taste the best.

Gallagher offers fast deliveries, and their drivers are friendly. So whether it is delivery, dine-in, or take-out, you’ll be more than satisfied.

 

11. Jake’s Pizza Green Bay

• Address: 112 S Broadway, Green Bay, WI 54303
• Phone Number: (920) 432-5253

Jake’s Pizza has been around for a very long time – as long as three decades. Obviously, staying that long in business may not be possible unless you have a cult following.

Jake’s Pizza has been serving delectable pizzas on the East side of Green Bay for 40 years. Now, sisters Brook and Cara are proudly continuing the legacy on the West Side.

The shop prepares the dough, sauces, and sausage fresh daily for you to enjoy. Though, most enthusiasts find their olive pizza spot on.

Also, be prepared for the extended serving time. It might take 45 minutes, especially if the oven is to capacity. But the good thing is that they have board and video games for the family to enjoy!

 

12. Great River Roadhouse – De Soto

• Address: 9660 Wisconsin 35, De Soto, WI 54624
• Phone Number: (608) 648-2045

Great River Roadhouse deals with homemade pizza, broasted chicken, homemade ribs, and pasta dishes. Their pizza is not only delicious. But the sizes here are also gigantic!

A small pizza is more than enough for two adults in this pizza joint. Although, adding a bit of Italian sausage can elevate the whole experience.

The ingredients are kept fresh by preparing them within the day. Some features found in their thin-crust pizza are black olives, mushrooms, onions, pepper, and pepperoni.

Although, there is one thing that may put you off – the cheese toppings. These guys aren’t cheap with the cheese, but they’d prefer something suitable for those who can afford it. Overall, it is still a family-oriented joint that delivers its brand well.

13. Olive’s Pizza And Sandwiches

• Address: 516 Greene Ave, Green Bay, WI 54301
• Phone Number: (920) 492-0732

The restaurant got its moniker from Olive, the owner’s cat. And many menu items are named after other furry friends.

The food is delicious and caters to all tastes, such as traditional pepperoni pizza and Nellie Mac & Cheese pizza. Thanks to their stone deck oven that creates perfectly crispy hand-tossed pizzas.

Along with this, the pizzeria also offers hot sub sandwiches and wings. But you can try out their flatbreads if you prefer a smaller option.

Now moving to quality of service, Olive’s is second to none. Why so? Because of their cultivated strong personal relationships with their customers and employees.

 

14. Luigi’s Pizza Kitchen & Restaurant

• Address: 2733 Manitowoc Rd., Green Bay, WI 54311
• Phone Number: (920) 468-4900

Luigi’s Italian Bistro is a must-visit when in Green Bay. Their pies are incomparable, especially their cheesy heavenly deep-dish pizzas. Also, not to mention the best burgers they offer.

The family-owned pizza place serves other Italian dishes, like pasta, in a rather casual setting. Services offered include dine-in, curbside pickup, and no-contact delivery.

Take some time off your busy schedule, or even one evening, and join the folks at Luigi’s in Kenosha. Their tastefully delicious pizza and friendly staff will blow you away.

 

15. T J Grizzlies

• Address: 4283 Co Hwy, Land O’ Lakes, WI 54540
• Phone Number: (715) 547-3700

This list of the best pizza places in Green Bay would not be complete without TJ Grizzlies. Their pizza is always baked fresh to order. Plus, they have homemade pasta and hot and fresh sandwiches from the oven.

Aside from it, I love the fact that chefs in this local pizzeria make hand-rolled fresh dough daily. But what caught my eye was the liberty to customize the pizza based on my cravings.

They also serve specialty pizzas at the T J Grizzlies. Some from the menu are the BBQ Chicken Pizza made with Sweet Baby Ray’s barbeque sauce, real Wisconsin mozzarella, and grilled chicken breast. You’ll never forget this one if you have a taste.

For the vegetarian in the family, T J Grizzlies has the best Veggie Pizza in town. You may top it with mushrooms, green peppers, and more organic options. Lastly, don’t forget to try their fresh and hot homemade soups rotating daily.

 

16. Papa Murphy’s Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

• Address: 1487 W Mason St, Green Bay, WI 54303
• Phone Number: (920) 497-0202

Unparalleled service, quality, and innovation – these are the three things you can expect from this pizzeria. But the third one is the reason behind their success as a food business. Hint! I’m talking about whatever toppings on pizza, including the controversial pineapple.

Papa Murphy also has loads of loyal guests, making them one of America’s Favorite Restaurant Chains in 2023 by Newsweek!

 

17. Rosati’s Pizza of Green Bay

• Address: 745 S Huron Rd, Green Bay, WI 54311
• Phone Number: (920) 468-4500

The five generations of the Rosati family held onto one humble philosophy—to give the people what they want. For decades, they’ve been serving Italian-style food in downtown Chicago. And none of the menus disappoints the palette of their customers.

You get the pizza fresh and hot, and the quality is just perfect every time. Aside from their pies, you also have to try their ribs and chicken. It’s absolutely amazing!

 

18. Toppers Pizza

• Address: 2042 Main St, Green Bay, WI 54302
• Phone Number: (920) 432-3232

Toppers Pizza believed that the decision about what goes in the pie is made inside the kitchen. And not in a boardroom where individuals debate on toppings that could be the next hit.

Aside from their core values, they also insist on using 100% real Wisconsin cheese to deliver the best order. I mean, who wouldn’t want a taste that follows the rigorous standards of the cheesemaking program?

 

Final Words

From small family businesses to famous pizza joints, you won’t run out of incredible pizza places to try in Green Bay, Wisconsin!

And I’m sure there are still loads to explore, like the Pizzeria Uno and Shamrock Pizza. So if you happen to pass by these places, let us know your keen thoughts on them!