15 Best Pizza Places in Peoria, IL (2023 Updated)

If you’re at the largest river city on the Illinois river, along with the great picturesque riverfront views, you’ll also get to relish crispy, chewy, and cheesy delicious pizzas.

15 Best Pizza Places in Peoria, IL pin

If you’re in Peoria for a short trip or if you’re local to this place and are searching for the next great pizza spot for you, you’re at the right place! These 15 pizza restaurants in Peoria will surely not disappoint you. Let’s begin our list with Italian-based Agatucci’s Restaurant!




This family-owned restaurant has been offering delicious pizzas and other Italian delicacies for almost a decade now. It was listed amongst the best pizzas in the state of Illinois by Thrillist in 2015.

Agatucci’s thin-crust pizzas are loved by many, and they say that their tiger sauce was the icing on the cake. So, don’t miss out on the sauce! And their fried chicken has also got rave reviews. So, if you don’t feel like pizza, you know what to order.

The atmosphere is polite and welcoming, and Agatucci’s love kids. So, if you’re planning to have a family dinner here, go ahead.

  • Address: 2607 N University St, Peoria, IL 61604, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-688-8200




Cheese Nuts Brickoven Pizzeria serves one of the best wood-fired pizzas in downstate Illinois.

Whether you’re new to this area or if you’re searching for a new pizzeria in your town, you must at least give Cheese Nuts a try. The portions are generous at Cheese Nuts, and the topping options available are commendable.

If you’re unsure what to order, go for their Bourbon pulled pork pizza – Puller pork, bacon, red onions, pineapple, house blend cheese, and sweet apple cider bbq drizzle. People have been raving about it!

And, for starters, order their crowd favorite –  cheese sticks. Wings at Cheese Nuts are amazing too!

  • Address: 5901 N Prospect Rd Suite 2, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-713-3866


3. Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North

Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North

Proudly owned and operated by Peoria natives, Oliver’s Pizza offers live music, trivia nights on Thursdays, games for kids, and even karaoke.

What’s more, the atmosphere also includes fun board games and dartboards as well. So, visit the restaurant with friends or family; Oliver’s has something in store for everyone.

Well-known for its excellent thin-crust pizzas, Oliver’s Pizza is also commended for its great selection of craft beers. Besides pizza, cheese curds and wings at Oliver’s are also to die for. So, don’t miss out on them!

  • Address: 3300 W Willow Knolls Dr, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-691-7891


4. Peoria Pizza and Works

Peoria Pizza and Works

If you ever have a late-night pizza craving, Peoria Pizza is your place! They offer dine-in, curbside pickup, and no-contact delivery services until 12 AM every day and until 1 AM only on Thursdays.

Peoria also offers a lunch buffet for $7.99 every day from 11 to 1:30. So, make sure you grab the deal!

Wednesdays at Peoria Pizza are trivia nights, and on Thursdays, there is an open mic. This pizzeria has truly become a staple in Peoria Heights. Order a deep-dish or Chicago-style pan crust pizza. Either way, you’re tastebuds are going to have a blast!

What’s more, from appetizers to drinks, Peoria Pizza does everything the best. So, if you’re around Peoria Heights, you know where to find the best service!

  • Address: 3921 N Prospect Rd, Peoria Heights, IL 61616, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-682-5446


5. Sugar Wood-fired Bistro

Sugar Wood-fired Bistro

When it comes to wood-fired pizzas, you can’t go wrong at Sugar Wood-fired Bistro! Their portions are generous, and the toppings combinations are truly unique.

Some of the crowd favorites at Sugar are BBQ chicken, Smokey pork chipotle, and Salmon BLT. Their mac and cheese is award-winning and meatloaf; where can we even begin to explain? Its’s divine!

So, for artisan pizzas and bread, Sugar is one of the best restaurants in Peoria. They also offer a modest selection of beers and wines. What else could anybody ask for?

  • Address:  826 SW Adams St, Peoria, IL 61602, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-676-0848


6. Monical’s Pizza

Monical’s Pizza

Monical’s pizza is situated at Knoxville Ave and Willow Knolls in Peoria. They offer one of the best thin-crust pizzas in Peoria. Food and service are great at Monical’s.

Order a delivery, dine-in, or if you’re in a rush, opt for a to-go. Via various fundraising programs such as pizza with a purpose and other donation programs, Monical’s Pizza also actively participates in giving back to the community.

The food is great, and the service people are amazing at Monical’s. In case you’re around, visit Monical’s for your next lunch/dinner. You won’t be disappointed!

  • Address: 4408 Knoxville Ave, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-688-0747
  • Address: 4100 W Willow Knolls Dr, Peoria, IL 61615, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-691-6477


7. Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza

Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza

Established in 2012, Brienzo’s has been serving their customer with the heavenly deliciousness of wood-fired thin-crust pizzas. Their pizzas are Neapolitan-style, and they hand toss their dough to achieve that premium Italian taste and texture.

Brienzo’s also offers great gluten-free crusts. Gluten-free or not, everybody enjoys Brienzo’s cauliflower crust pizzas.  Their draft beer and wine selections are also outstanding.

Besides pizzas, their beer cheese breadsticks and panini also seem to be crowd favorites. And, if you love gelato, that’s one more reason for you to choose Brienzo’s.

  • Address: Heritage Square, 4450 N Prospect Rd, Peoria Heights, IL 61616, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-966-4185


8. Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza

Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza

Nick-N-Willy’s like to call themselves Peoria’s best-kept secret! And we absolutely agree with that! Founded in 1996, Nick-N-Willy’s has been serving gourmet pizzas topped with farm-fresh ingredients since then.

Every bite of Nick-N-Willy’s crust is divine. Even if you aren’t a crust-eater, you’ll find yourself drooling over Nick-N-Willy’s crusts. They also offer a variety of gluten-free crust options.

The atmosphere is great, the pizzas are delicious, and the service is amazing! What else could anybody ask for from a pizza place?

  • Address: 4700 N University St #90, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-691-2345


9. Fedora’s Pizza & Deli

Fedora's Pizza & Deli

At Fedora’s, one cannot go wrong with their gyro pizza. Topped with gyro meat, onions, pepperoncini, and tomatoes, it is undoubtedly one of Fedora’s most loved gourmet pizzas. And the spinach pizza is equally great too.

The toppings are generously spread, and the pizzas are super cheesy at Fedora’s. If you don’t feel like pizza, try their spicy Italian sandwich; it has also got rave reviews!

The best part about this pizzeria is that it is relatively very affordable, and the portions are huge. At the moment, Fedora’s Pizza & Deli offers only the takeaway service.

  • Address: 1229 W McClure Ave # 1, Peoria, IL 61604, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-685-4976


10. Marco’s Pizza

Marco’s Pizza

Marco’s is probably one of the best chain pizzerias in Peoria. Opt for dine-in, curbside pickup, or delivery options as per your preference. It can be busy during the evenings.

The staffs at Marco’s Pizza are helpful and friendly, and the atmosphere is welcoming. However, you might find the prices a bit expensive, but their food quality is worth every penny.

For all the cheese fanatics out there, try their Big cheese pizza. You will not regret it! Even if you are on a gluten-free diet, you can go for their pizza bowl, i.e., no crust pizza. We guarantee you’ll love it. What’s not to love? It’s all cheese and fresh toppings!

  • Address: 708 W Glen Ave, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-689-6633


11. Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza

If you’re looking for a place to have a proper dine-in pizza session with your friends or family, you might want to skip on Little Caesars. These chain pizzerias only feature curbside pickup and delivery services.

You can find Little Caesars on Knoxville Ave, Sterling Ave, and Sheridan Rd#4 on Peoria. Their hand-tossed pizzas made using housemade dough are loved by many. Their chicken wings and breadsticks are also quite talked about.

But above all, Little Ceasars is famous for its reasonable prices and convenience. This chain has won America’s Best Value Winner award more times than any other restaurant chain. Isn’t that great?

  • Address: 4325 N Sheridan Rd #4, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-685-0049
  • Address: 3023 N Sterling Ave, Peoria, IL 61604, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-688-0235
  • Address: 9915 F, Knoxville Ave, Peoria, IL 61615, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-243-9700


12. Pizza Ranch

Pizza Ranch

Founded in 1981, Pizza Ranch today has around 207 locations across 14 states in the US. And the one in Peoria is definitely one of the local’s favorites.

They offer plenty of special pricing, and every Tuesday is Character Kid’s night. Though famous for their pizza buffet, fried chicken and mashed potatoes, and gravy are no less at Pizza Ranch. And their salad bar is undoubtedly one of the best in the city.

The staffs are friendly, the atmosphere is clean and welcoming, and the food is excellent. Pizza Ranch is truly one of the best chain eateries in Peoria.

  • Address: 4114 N Brandywine Dr, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-839-1420


13. Chicago Pizzeria

Chicago Pizzeria

Chicago Grill Pizzeria specializes in Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, hot dogs, sandwiches, and many other Chicago specialties. They opened their first restaurant in Chicago 25 years ago. So, it is obvious that they know every nook and crannies of Chicago food culture.

They use Grandma’s recipe to make their pizza dough, and the dough is tossed by hand and topped with fresh quality cheese and ingredients. Be it a night with friends or a family gathering, Chicago Pizzeria has something to offer for everyone.

Besides their specialties, they also serve amazing gyros. Overall, the food and ambiance at Chicago Pizzeria are really great. And, needless to say, you’ll definitely be back wanting for more!

  • Address: 814 W Pioneer Pkwy, Peoria, IL 61615, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-690-4745


14. Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC

Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC

Located in Tanglewood Center, Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC serves one of the best hearty hand-tossed pizzas in Peoria. The staff is very friendly, the service is great, and the prices seem to be pretty reasonable as well.

Currently, Fat Jack’s doesn’t offer dine-in services. But their takeaway and no-contact delivery services are timely and commendable. Their crust is chewy with a slight crunch, and the flavor is great. And the toppings are fresh and healthy.

The Quad City-style pizzas at Fat Jack’s are cut in rectangles instead of triangles and topped with loads of cheese. Besides pizza, this pizzeria also serves fantastic chicken wings. So, if you are around, you should definitely give Fat Jack’s Pizza a shot!

  • Address: 7016 N University St, Peoria, IL 61614, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-692-9000

15. Avanti’s Ristorante

Avanti’s Ristorante

Avanti’s Ristorante is an Italian chain serving pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and other Italian delicacies local to Peoria. Avanti’s is truly an American dream come true.

Albert Zeller, founder and CEO of Avanti’s, grew up in Switzerland, where he learned the art of cheese making and processing dairy products.

Using this knowledge, along with his understanding of business and his love for culinary, his brainchild Avanti’s Ristorante was born in 1966. And, this success story continues to live on to this date.

Along with their pizzas, Avanti’s is also famous for its gondolas. Dine-in in their relaxed atmosphere or opt for to-go or delivery. Either way, you’ll love Avanti’s!

  • Address: 8517 Knoxville Ave, Peoria, IL 61615, United States
  • Contact:  +1 309-691-2525
  • Address: 2320 E Washington St, East Peoria, IL 61611, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-694-6200
  • Address: 4711 N Rockwood Dr, Peoria, IL 61615, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-688-6565
  • Address: 1301 W Main St, Peoria, IL 61606, United States
  • Contact: +1 309-674-4923


Our main motto is to help out our readers. We’ve shared 15 of our favorite pizza places in Peoria, along with their addresses and contacts, for your ease.

From convenient chain eateries to proper dine-in Italian fancy restaurants, we’ve got something for all. We hope you have one of the best pizza experiences of your life while you’re in Peoria.

There might be many more hidden gems in Peoria that serve world-class pizzas. Have we missed out on your favorites? We’re all ears!

15 Best Pizza Places in Peoria, IL pin 2

1 thought on “15 Best Pizza Places in Peoria, IL (2023 Updated)”

Leave a Comment