14 Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL [2022 Updated]

Pizza has become one of the most popular meals worldwide. Italian cuisine resembles in many places. Or at least they try to.

14 Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL pin

If you are looking for the best pizzerias in Gainesville, FL, this article will be of help. Whether it is on a holiday or business trip, or you actually happen to live there, a thorough guide with places to enjoy a well-made pizza will always come in handy.

So, here is our selection of the best 14 pizza places in Gainesville, FL.

1. Gumby’s Pizza

Gumby’s Pizza
Image
  • Address: 2028 SW 34th St, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 374-8629
  • Google Rating: 4/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

With stores in several different locations, Gumby’s Pizza is proving itself to be not just a pizza franchise, but also a synonym of good quality.

Their internal philosophy is “don’t just satisfy the customers – impress them!”, which they fulfill in every delivery, Gumby’s Pizza will receive your order and have it ready within minutes.

Fine quality ingredients, such as fresh meat and vegetables accompany a dough made from scratch for every pizza. A must try when visiting Gainesville, FL.

A great addition to their delicious pizza is their “pokey stix” combo, a blend of garlic cheese bread that will complement for a perfectly crafted meal.

 

 

2. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
Image
  • Address: 200 NW 43rd St, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 371-7437
  • Google Rating: 4.6/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

Piesanos pizzeria is the place you must visit if you like stoned fired pizza. A request from many outsiders when visiting Gainesvile, FL, it has become popular for its good food quality and service.

Try their special rolls, dip them in marinara or their own personal sauce, and enjoy one of their various pizza alternatives.

They even have gluten free products for those who request them, so everyone is included in their menu.

You cannot leave Gainesville without trying Piesanos’ pizza Rustica. A combination of provolone, sauce and parmesan cheese on the ultra-thin dough.

 

 

3. Satchel’s Pizza

Satchel's Pizza
Image
  • Address: 1800 NE 23rd Ave, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 335-7272
  • Google Rating: 4.6/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

Satchel’s pizza place has got everything a pizzeria must have to be good. Quickness, and a great variety of loaded pies.

Apart from its great food, this restaurant has a great atmosphere. You will notice it is not a regular place, which is something they logically joke about. This makes it a perfect place to go with kids.

Great attention, a welcoming place, and great food makes Satchel’s the perfect place to go with friends or family.

Satchel’s is open Tuesdays through Saturdays, so it may get a little crowded given its popularity. Reservations are made through their website.

 

 

4. Blaze Pizza

Blaze Pizza
Image
  • Address: 3617 SW Archer Rd, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 458-5208
  • Google Rating: 4.7/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4.5/5

Generally, when we see a crowded place, we tend to think we are going to have a long waiting time. This is not so at Blaze Pizza, because their service is so good and fast you do not even notice what is going on.

Fresh, daily made dough, healthy ingredients – if that is what you are looking for – and a personalized pizza that perfectly adjusts to your taste buds.

As an additional feature, they have seasonal specials. If you love pizza, you must try them!

They also have a Blaze Rewards system, where you can register and get free stuff like meals, desserts, and drinks.

 

 

5. Leonardo’s Pizza of Millhopper

Leonardo's Pizza of Millhopper
Image
  • Address: 4131 NW 16th Blvd, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 376-2001
  • Google Rating: 4.6/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

If you are looking for a big load of gooey tasty cheese, this place has been created exactly for you. Leonardo’s is one of those places you know the first slice is due to hunger, but the second one is for the sake of pleasure.

Their Chicago-style pizzas will water your mouth just by browsing the menu. What is best, it will take more time for you to make a decision, than actually having the order served.

Sides at Leonardo’s Pizza of Millhopper follow the same line as their main specialty. Hand tied garlic knots will become your pizza’s best companion ever.

If you happen to need one of the best pizzas in the area, order the Big Leo, an all-time special this pizzeria does not grow tired of improving.

 

6. Humble Wood Fire

Humble Wood Fire
Image
  • Address: 127 SE Depot Ave, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 359-5153
  • Google Rating: 4.6/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

There is one thing where this places’ name has it completely wrong, and it is that it is not humble at all. Their wood-fired pizzas are something to really brag about.

Their tasty and well-varied pizzas will make a one-of-a-kind meal. A great place to enjoy one of the best pizzas in town.

As an additional, their hand-made bagels are a nice way to start your day. Have the best brunch ever with a starting roll and round it up with a delicious pizza.

Humble Wood Fire pizzeria works on an event-basis system, published on their website. Check for the next available event, and be sure to get there in time!

 

 

7. Satch Squared

Satch Squared
Image
  • Address: 405 SW 4th Ave, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 554-4484
  • Google Rating: 4.6/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 5/5

Satch Squared pizzeria is the special place for pizza lovers. Their square pizzas make this diner a unique place, from shape to taste.

Accessible topping options and a wide variety of fresh ingredients contribute to the expected result: a pizza you will never forget.

Gluten-free and vegan cheese are available to, so all audiences are included in Satch Squared pizzeria.

If visiting Gainesville, FL, you cannot miss the chance to visit this pizza place. And while you do so, give a try to their featured waffles and spend a whole morning eating great food!

 

 

8. Pleasant Street Pizza

Pleasant Street Pizza
Image
  • Address: 308 NW 5th Ave, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 792-6773
  • Google Rating: 5/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 5/5

Online ratings do not lie, and Pleasant Street Pizza really deserves its score. They really give pizza quite a turn-around.

If your thought is that healthy food is not meant to be tasty, this pizzeria will prove you wrong.

Natural Sourdough pizza, fresh vegetable toppings, and a balanced amount of cheese seemed carefully calculated to offer one of the best pies in Gainesville, FL.

Enjoy braised collards, shaved parmesan cheese, thin red onion, almonds, and olive oil with their newly featured “Verdura Pizza”. A must-try in Pleasant Street.

 

 

9. Peppino’s Pizza

Peppino's Pizza
Image
  • Address: 3731 W University Ave, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 554-6078
  • Google Rating: 4.7/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: N/R
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

Peppino’s pizza achieves to transmit the message every family-owned restaurant should. A warm environment, together with a homemade meal.

Go by the slice, or order a whole pizza. Peppino’s has a wide variety of ingredients and toppings to make a delight of your pizza experience.

You should try their calzones, and check if you can finish them! Big, tasty portions of stuffed dough are what make this place unique.

Peppino’s is open Tuesdays through Saturdays, so remember not to delay your visit should you be in the city’s whereabouts.

 

 

10. Scuola Pizza

Scuola Pizza
Image
  • Address: 5240 NW 34th Blvd, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 451-4122
  • Google Rating: 4.7/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4/5
  • Yelp Rating: 5/5

Scuola Pizza works under the philosophy of redesigning a dining experience. They are not only about the food, but also the environment.

Coming from Greek origins, this pizzeria brings Mediterranean flavors to Gainsville, FL. Enjoy an original, fresh-made pizza while reading some captivating literature.

Craft your own pizza choosing from a variety of meat and vegetable toppings, or try the personalized pita pizza with up to two toppings.

Leaving Scuola Pizza to decide what you eat is also a wise choice. Multiple Greek combinations of pre-designed pies, such as their Gyro pizza, will be a rewarding experience.

 

 

11. Amelia’s Italian Restaurant

Amelia's Italian Restaurant
Image
  • Address: 235 S Main St Suite 107, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 373-1919
  • Google Rating: 4.7/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

Amelia’s promise is that every guest will taste the difference from the very first bite. And, actually, you do.

Its Italian cuisine is made from scratch for every single order, and when it comes to pizza, this is no exception.

Under the motto of “Natural Cooking”, Amelia uses fresh ingredients and toppings to take pizza to the next level. They even offer videos on their website to teach you how to eat healthy, homemade food.

Available both for order and pickup Tuesdays through Sundays. Reservations are needed if you want to eat at the location.

 

 

12. Cacciatore Pizza and Kitchen

Cacciatore Pizza and Kitchen
Image
  • Address: 235 S Main St Suite 107, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 373-1919
  • Google Rating: 4.7/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

If thin crust pizza is your passion, then Cacciatore is the ideal place for you. Their Jersey-like dough is one of the most remarkable features of this pizzeria.

With carefully selected ingredients, such as their whole milk mozzarella cheese, or their imported oregano, Cacciatore makes a unique experience out of every order.

Choose from their Sicilian, White, or “Crunchy Bread” pizzas, among others, or add any other toppings to personalize your own pie. Whatever the choice, a perfect Italian-style meal is guaranteed.

And if you want to go with something different, Cacciatore’s calzones are worth the decision. You will not regret their creamy ricotta cheese, blended with a homemade gravy.

 

 

13. Italian Gator Pizza

Italian Gator Pizza
Image
  • Address: 1728 W University Ave, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 367-4600
  • Google Rating: 4.5/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4.5/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4.5/5

Tired of small deliveries that do not fulfill your palate’s requirements? Italian Gator Pizza has the perfect solution for you, with their Giant 20” pizza.

Personalize your Giant Cheese pizza to your demands, adding up to 3 toppings of the best fine-selected ingredients. What is best, you will get the pie of your like within minutes!

This pizzeria also includes other pre-designed toppings, such as their famous Giant White Pizza with Spinach, a definite must when visiting Gainesville, FL.

However, if you do not feel you can finish a whole pizza, you can always go for the slice. Their daily specials are a great option, too. And they are at a very accessible price!

 

 

14. MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza

MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza
Image
  • Address: 4949 Celebration Pointe Ave #100, Gainesville, FL
  • Phone: (352) 78-3030
  • Google Rating: 4.4/5
  • TripAdvisor Rating: 4/5
  • Yelp Rating: 4/5

If you feel you are ready to taste a genuine Neapolitan wood-fired pizza, then it is your time to visit MidiCi pizzeria. They really know how to make yourself feel close to the Mediterranean Sea.

Try a lightweight option, such as their Margherita, or go for an all-in pie with their Four Cheese pizza. Whatever the choice, you will surely not regret it.

You can take your pizza home, or choose to take your home to this pizzeria, as you enjoy a homemade crust in their garden, while sipping on a fine-selected wine of theirs.

Food is all about the experience, according to people at MidiCi, and they make sure they transmit that you every guest.

 

 

Conclusion

So, whether it is Italian, Jersey, New York, or even Greek style, Gainesville, FL has a lot to offer regarding pizzerias. The only thing you needed was a guide, and here it is!

Go for a whole round pie, just a slice or two, or even a square one. Options are infinite!

Have you been to any other pizzeria in Gainesville, FL that was not included? What was your experience? Comment, and share it with the community!

14 Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL pin 2

4.9/5 - (1444 votes)

Leave a Comment