15 Best Pizza Places in Pembroke Pines, FL [2023 Updated]

If you live in Pembroke Pines and want a pizza, where do you go? Whether you’ve just arrived in the area or want to try somewhere new, you’ll need some hot tips. The good news is, you’ve come to the right place!

15 Best Pizza Places in Pembroke Pines, FL pin

We’re going to check out 15 places to get the best pizza in Pembroke Pines. We’ll highlight what makes them great. And we’ll give you contact details to get in touch.

So read on and find the perfect choice for your next pizza night!

1. Coley’s Pizza

Coley’s Pizza
  • Address: 18381 Pines Boulevard, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33029
  • Tel: 954-433-4477

Coley’s Pizza offers a wide range of New York and Chicago style pizzas from its location in Shoppes of Silver Lakes. It’s open seven days a week, staying open an hour later to 11pm on Friday and Saturday nights.

There’s a great range of vegetables, meats and cheeses to create your own pie. Or you can choose from signature combinations like the Philly Fanatic, with thinly sliced steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and plenty of mozzarella. All the options are available in a choice of 14 or 18-inch pies.

Also on the menu are wings, salads, pasta, subs, calzones and Stromboli. Outside of pandemic restrictions you can dine in, or order your food for takeout, curbside pick-up or delivery.


2. Sano Food

Sano Food
  • Address: 2020 North Flamingo Road, Unit 34, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33028
  • Tel: 954-251-2967

Sano Food has a wide-ranging menu for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Pizza is just one of the options, but there are plenty of choices.

Start by choosing your preferred crust, either whole grain or cauliflower.  There’s a range of topping combinations, including more unusual options like goat cheese and apple. Or go for seafood, with both smoked salmon and tuna on offer.

Beyond the pizza, you can also create your own pasta, burger, sandwich, panini or wrap. There are plenty of salads, fruit bowls and extras. And the dessert menu is mouth-watering.


3. Pasquale’s Pizza

Pasquale’s Pizza
  • Address: 16660 Sheridan Street, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33028
  • Tel: 954-842-2575

Pasquale’s Pizza is open seven days a week, with late opening on Friday and Saturday nights. You can dine in, order takeout, or order online for curb-side collection or delivery.

This family-owned restaurant offers a wide selection of pizzas. You can find small and large round pies, 17-inch Sicilian pizzas, gluten-free crusts, and pizza by the slice. There’s a great range of toppings, and you can select them to go over half or a whole pie.

You can also get a small deep-fried calzone, or large baked version which will serve four people. Other options include Stromboli, pasta dishes, hot and cold subs, wings and salads. And there’s a good selection for children too.


4. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
  • Address: 11037 Pines Boulevard, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33026
  • Tel: 954-443-6610

Dine-in at Anthony’s and you’ll have the choice of the dining room or the dog-friendly patio. Alternatively, enjoy their food tucked up at home with their delivery or curbside pick-up services. It’s open seven days a week.

The pizzas here are cooked in a coal fired oven which reaches temperatures of 900 degrees Fahrenheit. The result is a crust that’s light and crispy, with some gentle charring at the edges.

The traditional base uses mozzarella, Italian plum tomato sauce and grated Romano cheese. There’s a choice of 12 or 16-inch pies, which will give you six or eight slices respectively. And there’s a small but tasty selection of toppings, with a good choice for both vegetarians and meat-eaters.

Anyone who’s watching their weight will be able to tot up their calories with ease. Calorie counts are given per slice of pizza and for each additional topping.


5. Sal’s Italian Ristorante

Sal’s Italian Ristorante
  • Address: 14535 South West 5th Street, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027
  • Tel: 954-239-0563

Whenever your pizza craving strikes, consider Sal’s Italian Ristorante. It’s open every day and offers dine-in, curbside pick-up and delivery.

There’s a choice of Famiglia or Gourmet pizzas. The latter includes topping combinations like Sal’s Favorite, featuring meatballs, ricotta cheese, Italian sausage, tomato sauce and mozzarella. There are plenty of options for vegetarians. And there are calzones and Stromboli too.

Beyond pizzas you’ll find soups, salads, wings, paninis, subs and wraps. There’s a vast selection of pasta, meat and seafood dishes. And if you want something sweet to finish your meal, you’ll find plenty of desserts on offer too.


6. Umberto’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

Umberto’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
  • Address: 1320 North University Drive, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33024
  • Tel: 954-432-5056

Umberto’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a great choice for those looking for authentic Italian cuisine. It’s open in the afternoons and evenings every day except Monday. You can dine in, or order your food for takeout, curbside pick-up or delivery.

Round pizzas are available in 10, 14 and 16-inch diameters. You can also choose a 16-inch square Sicilian pie. And there’s a Grandma’s pizza with a thicker crust.

Classic topping combinations include the Meatlovers, with meatballs, pepperoni, sausage and ham, and the Vegetable, with onions, mushrooms, bell peppers and spinach. You can also add any extra topping of your choice, whether on half or all of the pizza.

Small and large calzones are available too. And there’s also an appetizing selection of subs, salads, pasta dishes and entrées.


7. MOD

  • Address: 11255 Pines Boulevard #101, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33026
  • Tel: 754-465-5814

MOD is a counter-serve chain where you can dine in or order for takeout, curbside pick-up or delivery. It’s open every day, from 10.30am to 10pm Sundays through Wednesdays, closing at 11pm the rest of the week.

The classic MOD pizza has an 11-inch crust. But if you’re extra hungry, you can order the Mega dough. It’s the same diameter but has a much thicker crust. Alternatively, if you don’t want a big meal, choose the Mini. The 6-inch pizza is great for kids or those with smaller appetites.

There’s a wide range of toppings, whether you love meat or prefer to stick to vegetables. You’ll also find salads and sides. And all the options are calorie counted, helping you make healthier choices.


8. Amici’s Ristorante and Pizzeria

Amici’s Ristorante and Pizzeria
  • Address: 1629 N Hiatus Rd, Pembroke Pines, FL 33026
  • Tel: 954-431-4554

Head to Amici’s for great pizza and unpretentious Italian cooking. It’s open every day from 12 to 8.30pm, and you can dine in or choose takeout, curbside pick-up or delivery.

Choose from a classic cheese or create-your-own round pizza, or opt for a Sicilian instead. Calzones and Stromboli are on the menu too.

The range of pre-set toppings includes meaty options like Amici’s Loaded Pie, with pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onions, mushrooms and meatballs.

Vegetarians can pick pizzas like the Veddy Veggie, with Roma tomatoes, mushrooms, olives and green peppers, or Eggplant Italiano with fried eggplant, ricotta and tomatoes.

The extensive menu also includes appetizers, soups, salads, sides, hoagies, pasta, and chicken and seafood entrees. For dessert, there’s a choice of tiramisu or cannoli.


9. Dough Boys

Dough Boys
  • Address: 292 North West 172nd Avenue, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33029
  • Tel: 954-441-4480

The Miami Herald proclaimed Dough Boys the home of the best pizza. Try it out for yourself – it’s open every day to dine in, or order takeout or delivery.

The restaurant is cosy and busy, and the food is tasty. Choose from traditional or specialty round pizzas in 10, 12, 14 or 16-inch diameters. Or go for the Sicilian with its square, extra thick crust, measuring 16 inches. If you prefer, buy your pizza by the slice in standard, jumbo or deluxe sizes.

You can also opt for whole wheat or gluten-free crusts. And the impressive toppings list includes options like chicken marsala, tiger shrimp scampi and shaved sirloin steak.

Also on the menu are a wide selection of appetizers, soups, sides, salads, flatbreads, pasta dishes and entrees.


10. La Strega Cucina Italiana

La Strega Cucina Italiana
  • Address: 17864 North West 2nd Street, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33029
  • Tel: 954-441-3475

La Strega Cucina combines traditional Italian cooking with contemporary flourishes. It’s an approach mirrored in the restaurant’s interior, where you’ll find fragments of old walls contrasting with modern décor. It’s a great location to dine in, but you can also enjoy their food via takeout or delivery.

The pizzas here are simple and reasonably priced. Choose from a Margherita, marinara or Hawaiian (Hawaiana). There’s also a Calabrese (salami), Funghi (mushrooms), Quattro Stagioni (artichokes, mushrooms, olives and parma ham) and Rucula e Prosciutto (arugula and prosciutto).

Kids can have their own Margherita, or build their own pasta. And adults can also choose from the extensive menu of pasta, meat and seafood dishes, as well as some delicious desserts.


11. California Pizza Kitchen

California Pizza Kitchen
  • Address: 11401 Pines Boulevard, Space 100, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33026
  • Tel: 954-432-1498

The Pembroke Pines branch of chain California Pizza Kitchen is rated highly by regulars. Here you’ll find all the CPK favorites, with daily opening and dine-in, takeout or delivery options. Patio seating is available, and there’s a full bar.

All the pizzas offer six slices, and there’s a calorie count per slice for those watching their weight. You can choose a gluten-free crust. And there are loads of vegetarian options, plus seafood (shrimp scampi) and a range of meaty toppings for committed carnivores.

You can combine the convenience of takeout with the taste and aroma of home cooking with the Take ’n’ Bake pizza range. Your pie will be made from scratch to your specifications. Then just take it home and pop it in your own oven.

If you fancy something besides pizza, there are soups, salads, pasta, small and large plates, sandwiches and desserts.


12. Jersey John’s Pizzeria

Jersey John’s Pizzeria
  • Address: 10460 Taft St, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33026
  • Tel: 954-430-8881

You can find Jersey John’s Pizzeria in Pembroke Lanes Shopping Plaza. It’s open seven days a week, closing at 10pm except on Sundays when it’s 9pm. There’s no dine-in option, but you can order takeout, arrange curbside pick-up or get your food delivered.

The pizzas come in a choice of regular or thin crust, with the option of create-your-own or pre-set toppings. These include staples like the Meatzza, with pepperoni, sausage, ham, meatballs and extra cheese.

There are four vegetarian options, including the Veggie, featuring mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives and extra cheese. But note there’s no gluten-free selection here.


13. Pizza Machine

Pizza Machine
  • Address: 8955 Taft St, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33024
  • Tel: 954-437-3333

Pizza Machine is open daily. And when you place your first order for delivery via GrubHub, you’ll get $10 off your bill. You can order online, by phone, or by dropping in at the restaurant. But note that there’s no dine-in service here.

The pizza dough is tossed by hand and you can choose from the traditional or thin crust. Classic pies are available from 12 inches to a whopping 28 inches in diameter. And you can also choose a Sicilian pizza or a cheese pizza by the slice with your own selection of toppings.

Those with gluten intolerance can opt for a 14-inch gluten-free crust. Also on the menu are a wide selection of Italian entrées, burgers, subs, sides and salads. And the desserts here are seriously tempting.


14. Fantasy Pizza and Salad

Fantasy Pizza and Salad
  • Address: 10800 Pines Boulevard, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33026
  • Tel: 954-435-1062

Sports-themed Fantasy Pizza is a great spot to enjoy your food whilst watching the game on a big-screen TV. And if you prefer to eat at home, you can collect your food or have it delivered.

The menu features a great range of pizzas and salads, all freshly made and tasty. Also available is a good selection of appetizers, subs and pastas. Those with a sweet tooth are well catered for by the dessert menu. This features options like red velvet cake, chocolate cake and cannoli.

It’s open every day. Check the website for up-to-date opening hours.


15. Santino’s Pizza and Pasta

Santino’s Pizza and Pasta
  • Address: 18267 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33029
  • Tel: 954-441-0080

Find Santino’s in the Shoppes of Silver Lakes. You’ll get $12 off your first order when you get delivery via GrubHub. And you can dine-in or arrange for curb-side pick-up too.

You’ll be spoilt for choice, with the menu featuring not only pizzas but calzones, Stromboli, salads, subs, appetizers, pasta and seafood. Round pizzas are available in 14 and 16-inch diameters, and there’s also the option of a 16-inch square Sicilian.

If a whole pie is too much, you can order by the slice instead. Choose one of the gourmet topping combos – we love the Seafood, with shrimp and clams. Or add your own to a whole or half pie, or by the slice.

Santino’s is open until 10pm, seven days a week.


Ready for pizza?

That brings us to the end of our list of 15 places to get the best pizza in Pembroke Pines! Whatever type of pizza you’re craving, and whatever your budget, there are some great options out there.

Whether you want thin crust or pan, Neapolitan or Sicilian, meat, vegetable or seafood, we hope you’ve found something to tickle your tastebuds. Enjoy your next pizza!

15 Best Pizza Places in Pembroke Pines, FL pin 2

Leave a Comment