Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: What’s the Difference?

If you’re wondering the difference between Domino’s hand-tossed pizza and the Brooklyn-inspired option, you’re in the right place. In a nutshell, both are handmade, and their doughs are first kneaded and then stretched or tossed before they are baked.

Neither pizza option are baked in a deep-dish pan, but they’re placed in thinner aluminum pans to make them crunchier than the likes of Domino’s hand pan pizza.

Domino's Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed What's the Difference 1

The main difference between Domino’s Brooklyn style vs. hand tossed pizza is their size and crunchiness. While the Brooklyn style pizza is thinner and crunchier, the hand tossed pizza is thicker with a chewy crust.

Also, the Domino’s pizza chain introduced the Brooklyn style to give customers the authenticity and experience New Yorkers usually get.

The company is essentially offering a New York-style pizza to other parts of America. Thanks to its thin and wide slices, the Brooklyn-inspired pizza feels New York because you can actually fold it while eating – just like a real New Yorker!

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: What Sets Them Apart?

Unlike Domino’s hand tossed pizza, the Brooklyn-style option is hand-stretched to make it a little thinner. Its slices are also wider, and the crust is crunchier than the hand tossed pizza.

Its uniqueness comes from the fact that its dough is not only hand-stretched, but it has less moisture, which is how it’s baked in New York. Everything is handmade – from kneading to stretching to placing on the pan.

The process of its baking feels so authentic. Best of all, Domino’s Brooklyn-style pizza is distinctive because of the pepperoni. On the other hand, the hand tossed pizza has lots of cheese on it compared to the Brooklyn pizza.

The Brooklyn-style pizza is perfect for those who prefer less dough. Its crust is thin and is cooked with cornmeal to give it the desired crispiness. Its crust’s thickness falls between the hand-tossed pizza and Domino’s “Crunchy Thin” options.

Domino’s Brooklyn’s Style vs. Hand Tossed: Which Tastes Better?

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed Which Is Healthier

Well, it depends on you. Do you love more cheese or more pepperoni? If it’s the latter, then the Brooklyn-style pizza is perfect for you. But if you prefer cheese, then the hand tossed is what you should order.

The Brooklyn-style pizza is crustier, and the sauce tastes rather natural and authentic. That doesn’t mean that the hand tossed pizza isn’t natural, but it’s also tastier because of the garlic oil it’s seasoned with once cooked. The Brooklyn-style isn’t seasoned with garlic, but it’s baked with regular cheese and provolone added to it.

A native New Yorker may criticize Domino’s Brooklyn-style pizza for not being as good as those made in New York or New Jersey; however, the pizza comes close. And it’s worth giving it a shot.

Which Is Healthier?

Since the Brooklyn-style Domino’s pizza has a thinner crust, it’s expected to be healthier than the hand tossed. This is not solely because of the crust size, Duh! But it’s mainly because Domino’s hand-tossed pizza has more cheese, meaning you’ll be taking in more calories.

The larger crust in hand tossed pizza contains more fat, more sodium, and more salt. But that’s why its slices are smaller, so make sure to share the pizza with family and friends.

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: How Thick Are They?

Domino's Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed How Thick Are They

the Brooklyn-style pizza isn’t gummy and is less fluffy than the hand-tossed option. Instead, it’s a very thin pizza with a less doughy crust and a crispier taste.

The Brooklyn-style is also lighter than the hand tossed pizza. You can actually fold the Brooklyn pizza like a true New Yorker.

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: How Are They Prepared?

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed How Are They Prepared

While both the Hand-tossed and Brooklyn-style Domino’s pizzas are made of the same dough, the latter is prepared using a smaller patty. This makes the Brooklyn-style pizza’s dough easier to stretch, making it thinner than the hand tossed.

The Brooklyn-inspired pizza also has a much smaller crust, which makes the slices wider. This means the pizza comes with only 6 slices compared to hand-tossed pizza of 8 slices.

As expected, the Domino’s hand tossed option has a thick crust that’s chewier than the Brooklyn-style pizza. Because of the thickness, the hand-tossed pizza doesn’t fold easily.

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: When Is It Best to Order Either?

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed When Is It Best to Order Either

If you’ve got a big appetite, both pizza options are satisfying enough. The difference is that some folks may prefer a pizza with more pepperoni, and that’s when the Brooklyn-style will have more fans. But for those who love more cheese, then the hand tossed is preferable.

If you have a party consisting of traveling New Yorkers, then it’s best to serve the Brooklyn-style pizza – to remind them of something they are used to eating back home. A native New Yorker will definitely love the foldable slices.

Domino’s Brooklyn-style pizza mimics New York’s original pizza. And even though it doesn’t match what New Yorkers are used to, Domino’s Brooklyn-inspired pizza comes very close.

Other than New York natives reminiscing to taking the Brooklyn-style, you’ll love its thin crust.

However, if you’re not into more pepperoni but prefer cheese on cheese pizzas, go with the hand tossed. Both pizzas are great for parties and sleepovers.

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: How Do They Compare?

Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed How Do They Compare

While the hand tossed is seasoned with garlic once baked, the Brooklyn-style is cooked using regular cheese. This is why Domino’s Brooklyn-style pizza tastes less cheese-y, and more pepperoni-like, than the hand tossed.

The hand tossed pizza is thicker in the crust than the Brooklyn pizza, whose dough is hand-stretched to size. The hand-tossed pizza is self-explanatory, meaning that its dough is tossed in the air before being baked.

And with more cheese on it – more than the pepperoni – the hand-tossed pizza is arguably tastier but less healthy because you’ll be taking more calories.

A notable difference between the two pizzas is their crispiness, where the Brooklyn-styled option is much crispier, thanks to its hand-stretched dough and addition of provolone. The hand-tossed pizza is chewier because of more dough and cheese on it.

However, this doesn’t mean Domino’s Brooklyn pizza isn’t chewier. It’s crispier on the outside and soft and fluffy on the inside.

FAQs on Domino’s Brooklyn Crust vs. Hand Tossed

FAQs on Domino's Brooklyn Crust vs. Hand Tossed

Let’s have a look at a few commonly asked questions regarding Domino’s pizza.

1. Do These Pizzas Come in Small, Medium, or Large Sizes?

Both options come in medium sizes. However, the Brooklyn-style pizza comes with 6 slices while the hand tossed option comes with 8 thick slices.

2. What’s the Difference in Packaging Between Domino’s Brooklyn Style and Hand Tossed?

The hand tossed pizza comes in a black box whereas the Brooklyn style comes in white. Both packagings are adorned with respective branding names “hand tossed” and “Brooklyn-style.”

3. How Tasty is Domino’s Brooklyn Style Pizza?

Without a doubt, the New York pizza always comes top. The pizza is a tribute to what’s served in New York, New Jersey, and even Connecticut.

Although it doesn’t really match New York’s original pizza, the Brooklyn-styled option is just as authentic and tastes good. Its pepperoni, sauce, cheese, and crust are equally tasty compared to New York’s original. The crust is also wide and thin enough to fold while eating.

4. How Does the Brooklyn-style Domino’s Pizza Compare with the Thin Crust?

Both are thinner than the hand tossed pizza; however, the Thin Crust is much thinner than the Brooklyn-style option.

In fact, the Thin Crust is so thin that it may feel like a cracker, but it retains some dough to make it soft and a bit crunchier. The Thin Crust pizza incorporates Domino’s robust tomato sauce, although it’s hard to tell the difference.

Nonetheless, both the Brooklyn-styled and the Thin Crust pizzas have a nice blend of salty and sweet tastes. Both are also great for those who prefer less doughy pizzas.

Hand Tossed vs Domino's Brooklyn Style

5. How Much Calories Does Domino’s Pizza Have?

Statistics show that a slice of hand tossed Domino’s pizza contains about 290 calories. The same slice also comes with 11 grams of fat, 640 mg of sodium, and 25 mg of cholesterol. This makes it the unhealthiest pizza of the options.

A healthy American should be consuming approximately 40 to 80 grams of fat per day. So this means that one piece of a hand tossed pizza provides more than what you already need for fat each day. I guess that’s why healthy people go for Domino’s gluten-free pizzas.

6. Is There a Difference Between Hand Tossed and Hand Pan Domino’s Pizza?  

Let’s put the Brooklyn-style pizza aside and compare Domino’s hand tossed vs. hand pan pizzas. The names are self-explanatory. One is “hand tossed” before baking, while the other is placed on an oiled pan to cook.

The hand-pan pizza has a thick crust and is crunchy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. With the hand-tossed, the dough is not placed on a pan, but is tossed in the air to find the right shape. It’s then baked using a thin aluminum pan.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to the best pizza, Domino’s takes the lead. Other than being the tastiest pizzas, Domino’s pizzas are much easier to order. In comparing Domino’s Brooklyn style vs. hand tossed pizzas, the main difference is that the Brooklyn-inspired pizza is thinner and wider and comes in 6 slices. The hand-tossed pizza, on the other hand, comes in 8 thick slices.

Regarding taste, the Brooklyn-style pizza has more pepperoni, and its crust is crispier than the hand tossed option, which has more cheese. The hand tossed pizza is accentuated with garlic oil.

The Brooklyn style pizza is mainly for parties made of New Yorkers reminiscing and missing their families and friends back home. But this isn’t just for New Yorkers who are away from home. It’s a great pizza option if you’re looking for a pizza that’s tasty and healthy in equal measure.

Unlike the hand-tossed pizza, the Brooklyn-style pizza doesn’t have so many calories.

Nonetheless, it all depends on what you like. If you are a cheese guy, then the hand-tossed pizza is the perfect option. And if you are more like a pepperoni guy, then go with the Brooklyn-style Domino’s pizza.

Domino's Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed What's the Difference 3

3 thoughts on “Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed: What’s the Difference?”

  1. Note to the village idiots. You can easily fold hand tossed slices too. Only an imbecile would claim that Brooklyn is foldable and HT isn’t.

  2. Really John Q Publico

    …. I’m glad you’re the only smart person online to recognise that. Wow … you can fold hand tossed?! I can’t believe that . No one knew that, just you. Maybe it’s better to not talk , that way people won’t know if you have any kind of wisdom or sense instead of opening your mouth and letting everyone know.


Leave a Comment