If you reside in Fort Myers, or you’ve just moved in and looking for a great pizzeria, there are a number of places to check out. Here’s a list of 15 amazing pizza places to try.
1. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
- Address: 780 Grand Blvd Suite 100, Miramar Beach, FL 32550–7873
- Phone: (239) 432–9767
If you’re looking for fresh pizza, the Grimaldi’s is your go to pizzeria. The cooks use fresh ingredients and a coal-fired brick oven to prepare the pizza. This guarantees an authentic taste.
I recommend trying the Quartro Formaggi Pizza with mushroom and garlic. You can complement this with their in-house cheesecake and salad. You’ll need to spare some room for the cheesecake, or have it as a takeaway.
I love that Grimaldi’s Pizzeria changes flavors occasionally to keep things fresh. You can either order for home deliveries or dine in at the pizzeria. The servers are very friendly and always happy to cater to your needs.
The pizzeria is nestled at the Heart of Fort Meyers, at the Bell Tower Shops. You can locate it at the Regal 20 Cinemas, directly across the parking lot. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria has two outdoor patios, installed with heaters and fans perfect for all weather.
2. Blue Moon Pizza
- Address: 7381 College Parkway, Fort Myers, FL 33907
- Phone: (239) 936-2583
If you love home cooked pizza and tired of doing it yourself, or perhaps you don’t have the time, then Blue Moon Pizza is what you need.
You can either order the pizza or visit the pizzeria for outdoor dining. I prefer the latter.
The manager and servers are friendly and very homely. They are attentive to detail and their sole objective is to make sure your pizza is cooked exactly as requested.
When I visited the place, I was very specific with my request, which was annoyingly detailed. Luckily, the server was patient enough to catch everything I needed.
When the pizza was ready, it was the best pizza I’ve tasted. The crust was really good. And the pizza was crispy.
The Blue Moon Pizza also serves vegetarian options. And as a full time restaurant, you can enjoy other menu items. This is an advantage if you’re looking to spend time with family members, some of whom may prefer an alternate dish.
3. Domino’s Pizza
- Address: 4550 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905
- Phone: Use this link to find and CALL nearest Domino’s delivery
This doesn’t come as a surprise. The country’s leading pizza outlet also has a branch in Fort Meyers, Florida. As expected, Domino’s pizza is delicious and the crust is crispy and very tasty.
Domino’s has always been a committed pizza outlet. It offers a variety of creative pizza options.
Most of their menu items aren’t disappointing to your palate. Just pick your favorite pizza – handmade crusts, Brooklyn crusts, etc.
You can also go with their vegan and vegetarian options. But I wouldn’t advise if you’ve been diagnosed with celiac disease – but that’s another post for another day.
Anyways, domino’s pizza is usually delicious and their deliveries very fast. And it’s the best option if you’re not interested in an outdoor dining. You’ll love the tracking device domino’s has for its drivers.
4. Downtown House of Pizza
- Address: 1520 Hendry St Fort Myers, FL 33901
- Phone: 239-337-3467
For those who love laid back neighborhoods and appreciate Italian eats, the Downtown House of Pizza is an amazing place to be.
You can take your family for a pizza eat-out where you’ll find a great back patio to relax and unwind. Or maybe you’re the nocturnal type and can’t seem to sleep, Downtown House of Pizza serves until 3am.
The pizzeria is so cool that you may not find space to sit. The same is for pick-ups and takeaways. However, the line might be long but it moves fast.
At Downtown Pizza House, pizza is made from scratch with fresh ingredients. Being an Italian pizzeria, expect authentic pizza that’s hand tossed to produce crispy crusts.
Downtown House of Pizza has an open kitchen where you can watch their chefs do their magic. Other than using quality meat and cheeses, the pizzeria doesn’t forget vegans and vegetarians.
5. Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza
- Address: 2225 First Street, Fort Myers, FL 33901
- Phone: 239-337-COAL (2625)
Do you love Al Capone? Or do you love Italian mob movies? This comes close to the Italian culture you watch on movies – at least the setup.
The pizza is truly Italian and delicious. The place is domed with historical memorabilia of All Capone’s reign as the leader of Italian gangsters.
The servers are amazing too. They are very polite and surprisingly patient (given it’s an Al Capone inspiration LOL!)
Whatever request you make, they have you covered and your pizza comes exactly as you wanted it. Some of their suggestions are great too.
Dining at Capone’s Pizza in Fort Meyers is a delight. And the experience is truly wonderful. You should definitely give it a try.
If you feel like staying indoors, you can also make an online order for a delivery.
They don’t have reservations for people more than six, but you can put your name on the list then wait at the bar.
6. Fine Folk Pizzas
- Address: 11300 Lindbergh Blvd #114, Fort Myers, FL 33913US
- Phone: Call (239)-600-7373 for catering. And call (239)-313-5155 for quick deliveries.
This is arguably the best New York-style pizza in Fort Meyers. And that’s a statement from original New Yorkers living in Fort Meyers.
You’ll find many New Yorkers at this pizzeria catching up and reminiscing on old good NY pizza.
The place has amazing sidewalk seats where you can enjoy your handmade pizza, which comes with delicious desserts.
The servers at Fine Folk Pizza are keen to your requests. You can ask for anything and they will have you sorted out ASAP.
The crust and sauce combination of their pizza is what keeps the pizzeria ahead of its competitors.
The best thing though is their use of fresh ingredients only. And you’ll definitely love the culture they’ve built – which is so New York-ey but awesome.
Oh yes, the Fine Folk Pizza has had its pizza win awards. And that’s coz the pizza dough is not only hand tossed but also topped with salsa-inspired sauce.
7. Bellacino’s Pizza
- Address: 9377 6 mile cypress pkwy, Fort Meyers
- Phone: +1 239-277-0600
Looking for a kid-friendly pizzeria? The Bellacino’s is the best place for a family outing on a Sunday afternoon.
The atmosphere is great and the people are amazing. The servers are professional and very polite. They know how to deal with noisy and stubborn kids.
The pizza is really good. The Bellacino’s Pizza menu offers Pepperoni, Cheese, and Mozzarella pizzas. The sauce and toppings are also amazing.
The ingredients are fresh too. If you don’t fancy a dine in at Bellacino’s Pizza, you can also make an online order.
8. Buddyz Chicago Pizzeria
- Address: 3268 Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905
- Phone: +1 239-275-7777
Originally from Chicago, the pizzeria offers fresh and delicious pizza. It’s the best place for Chicago natives looking for something that tastes like their pizza back home.
The place is amazing too. It’s clean and spacious enough to allow dining with your entire family.
The pizza’s dough is hand tossed and the sauce made from scratch, and then blended with cheese and olive oil. The crust comes out crispy and a little bit crunchy – just good enough.
You have to try the Buddyz Chicago Pizza and get to enjoy lots of sauce options they offer. The pizza’s size is huge. This lets you leave some for the next day.
9. Bella’s New York Style Pizza
- Address: 1918 Boys Scout Drive, Fort Meyers 33907
- Phone: +1 239-275-4800
All I can say is go and try them out. Their pizza is to die for. And don’t let its hole-in-the-wall location be a put off.
Actually, that’s exactly what makes Bella’s Pizzeria unique.
The personnel is amazing and ready to fulfill all your needs. The owner even comes to introduce himself and ask if you need anything. That’s so cool! His name is Sal by the way.
The intention of Bella’s Pizza is to cook New York style pizzas. And that’s a feat the cooks at Bella’s are successful at.
I love that the pizza and garlic knots come in a petite and no frills setting. The pricing is fair and they have a takeaway bag if you’re full before finishing your pizza slices.
10. Tony N.Y. Pizza
- Address: 3398 Forums Blvd, Fort Myers Florida
- Phone: +1 239-931-7991
If you loathe soggy pizza, like I do, you don’t have to worry about it. This is coz Tony N.Y. Pizza offers pizza cooked using a stone deck.
And yes, the pizzas are hand tossed to ensure the crusts are crispy and tasty. The slices are also large and foldable, exactly like New York’s finest.
For New Yorkers, it can be really hard finding a great pizzeria in Fort Meyers, Florida. But the Tony N.Y. Pizza lives up to its expectations.
Apart from the tasty pizza, Tony N.Y. Pizzeria has a great atmosphere. The décor is filled with signs and images of New York – a perfect way to sooth that homesick feeling.
11. Friend’s Pizza Fort Meyers
- Address: 3441 COLONIAL BLVD UNIT 10, Fort Myers, FL 33966
- Phone: +1 239-418-1800
Just as the name suggests, the pizzeria is truly a friendly place. You’ll love both the pizza and the kind of service offered.
Friend’s Pizza at Colonial Blvd, Fort Meyers is a great place for a family outing. The atmosphere is amazing and the interior design and décor is of unique taste.
You can make a reservation with the pizzeria. Or you can simply order online using their cool app, which helps you track the delivery guy.
The deliveries are pretty fast too. And only takes a couple of minutes.
12. Citrola’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Address: 8841 College Parkway, Fort Myers, FL 33919
- Phone: 239.466.1113
If you love pizzerias located in quiet and unfussy neighborhoods, you’ll definitely love Citrola’s Pizzeria in Fort Meyers.
The place is so cozy and has a romantic feeling to it. A great place for proposal, right?
Anyways, if you decide to dine in at Citrola’s Pizza, I recommend getting a seat at its outdoor garden. But if the seats are filled out, they still have large and spacious rooms.
I did a little digging and found out the pizzeria is owned by an Italian. It means the pizza is cooked using original New York methods. This shows with the pizza’s quality and the décor, which is stylish and kinda feels New Yorkey.
13. Little Caesars Pizza
- Address: 12125 S Cleveland Avenue, Fort Meyers, Fl. 33907 – 3744
- Phone: +1 239-985-9440
When it comes to simplicity, Little Ceasars Pizza takes the lead. The pizzeria offers quality at high value. And the service is quick.
The place is not only great with an amazing atmosphere, but it’s way better and affordable than expensive establishments.
The price is right too. The staff members are very friendly and always on their feet to fulfill whatever it is you request.
I love how clean the place is, and that it has plenty of parking at the front.
The Little Caesars Pizza has delicious pizzas and don’t let the affordable price assume the pizza isn’t great, coz it is.
If you are not the outdoorsy type, you can call and make an order for delivery at your doorsteps.
14. Pizza D-Lux
- Address: 6810 Shoppes at Plantation Dr. Suite 1, Fort Meyers, Fl. 33912 – 4313
- Phone: +1 239-278-3589
Not many pizza places we’ve mentioned serve slices. But the Pizza D-Lux lets you request pizza slices in whichever toppings you like.
This makes the pizzeria a great place to have lunch, especially if you’re taking a break from work.
The Pizza D-Lux is actually located near business areas thus its main objective is to service lunch to employees in nearby offices.
The pizza is excellent. The crust is crispy, thin, light and a little bit airy. And the char flavor is just perfect.
The sauce has the right balance of sweet and herbs. The cheese and pepperoni are also well balanced.
Oh yeah, the pizza is foldable too. And doesn’t sag as well.
15. Hungry Howie’s Pizza
- Address: 525 Pine Island Rd, North Fort Meyers
- Phone: +1 239-995-9100
Well, natives of Fort Meyers know that Hungry Howie’s is where you go if you went flavored pizza crusts, such as garlic herb and sesame.
The pizza is great too. That’s because the dough is made fresh, which is then filled with chunks of beef, cheese and mushrooms.
The Hungry Howie’s is located at a convenient place for easy pick up, especially after you’re done with your shopping at the mall.
The pizzeria also has easy access to business regions.
The servers are friendly and very professional. If you order online, the drivers are fast and deliver pizza on time.
Verdict
With such a slew of pizzerias, it’s an advantage for you and I coz of the many varieties to pick from. You can choose a pizza place based on your moods or preferences.
While some of these pizza places in Fort Meyers focus on providing a family friendly dining experience, others specialize in cooking New York style pizza.
It all depends on your preference, as well as your palate. So good luck choosing what works best for you.
Barbara is an enthusiastic food-exploring person that goes through different culinary experiences. She got inspired by creating a pizza blog post after she tasted one of the best-selling pizzas in Toledo.