17 Best Pizza Places in Santa Fe, NM [2023 Updated]

If you’re in New Mexico and looking for quality pizza, we’re here to help! We’re going to take a look at 17 places to get the best pizza in Santa Fe.

Whether you’re looking for thin crust or pan, classic toppings, or something different, we’ve got you covered.

So step this way to find out where to place your order when your pizza craving strikes!

1. Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza

• Address: 321 W San Francisco St, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
• Tel: 505-986-8700

Located in Santa Fe’s plaza, Il Vicino serves pizzas made in an authentic wood-fired pizza oven. The surroundings are relaxed but sleek. And they even provide their own classic brew – an internationally award-winning beer called Canteen.

Also, you can eat outdoors – a boon in pandemic times. And if you’d rather stay home, you can have your food delivered. They will even cater for events – but ensure to contact the team for details first.

The menu features a range of classic Italian toppings. The Molto Carne takes the traditional meat feast up a level, with homemade sausage and Capocollo ham added to the pepperoni. Vegetarians have a decent choice of toppings. That includes fresh and healthy vegetables like artichoke hearts, kalamata olives, and many more.

And if you prefer, you can create your pizza. You can choose from four varieties of bases with sauces and over 20 toppings.

 

2. Back Road Pizza

• Address: 1807 2nd St #1, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
• Tel:  505-955-9055

This friendly pizzeria is an excellent choice for those looking for a crunchy crust and fresh, abundant toppings pie. In pandemic times, food is limited to curbside collection. At other times, you can dine in and watch as the pizzaiolo craft the pie. But you can also check their pool tables upstairs after your meal to keep you entertained.

The menu features a good range of pizzas, all with a crust rolled in cornmeal to give it extra crunch. You can choose from ‘cutie’ to large size, with a 12-inch gluten-free version available. Additionally, they offer plenty of topping options for those who like to customize their own.

You can even order your DIY pizza kit to replicate the Back Road experience at home. And inexperienced cooks needn’t worry – it comes with instructions too!

3. Upper Crust Pizza

Downtown:

• Address: 329 Old Santa Fe Trail, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
• Tel: 505-982-0000

El Dorado:

• Address: 5 Colina Drive, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87508
• Tel: 505-471-1111

Upper Crust Pizza has two branches in Santa Fe. In regular times, both offer a great dine-in experience. But you can order from both locations for delivery, and the El Dorado branch has a drive-thru too.

The wholewheat crust and marinara sauce are particular hits. It comes in two sizes only, either you go big or small. Also, the menu has plenty of choices for meat-eaters and vegetarians, like cheesy sandwiches and refreshing salads.

But if you plan to meet your sweet tooth, don’t forget to check their dessert tab. You can get a delicious strawberry or turtle cheesecake from the downtown Upper Crust. But head to El Dorado, and you’ll get lots more choices, including brownies, apple pie, empanadas, chocolate cake, and banana bread.

 

4. Pizza Centro

Downtown:

• Address: 418 Cerrillos Road, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
• Tel: 505-988-8825

Southside:

• Address: 3470 Zafarano Drive, Suite D, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87507
• Tel: 505-471-6200

At Pizza Centro, you can buy your pizza in 12 or 16-inch versions. There’s a good range of toppings, whether you order from the menu or create your own. Both vegetarians and meat-eaters have plenty to choose from. And you can buy classic pepperoni and specialty pizzas by the slice too.

There’s also a 12-inch gluten-free crust. But those with a gluten intolerance might feel peeved at paying the same price for their toppings as for a 16-inch pizza.

Aside from the pizzas, there’s a wide variety of salads, homemade Pacchetto, and a few sides. And if you want dessert, there’s gelato too.

 

5. Esquina Pizza

• Address: 403 S Guadalupe St, Santa Fe, NM 87501
• Tel: 505-303-3034

There are three words best to describe this pizzeria, that is local, fresh, and wood-fired. Why so? Their ingredients come from local farmers and producers in New Mexico. That’s why you can expect the menu to change based on what is available and when the innovation spark.

Esquina has an array of pizza flavors, from spicy ones to savory combinations. They also have starters and salads on the board while you’re waiting for your pie to cook.

Lastly, you can also check out their sister restaurant, Paloma, located next door. They offer lively dishes featuring authentic and fresh interpretations of Mexican cuisine. From salsas to guacamole, and Enmoladas to fajitas. For us, it’s a cultural feast you don’t want to miss when you visit the city.

6. Dion’s

St. Michaels and Cerillos

• Address: 2014 Cerrillos Road, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
• Tel: 505-424-7333

Las Soleras (I-25 and Cerillos)

• Address: 4980 Promenade Boulevard, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87507
• Tel: 505-501-6060

Dion’s has branches all over New Mexico, besides Colorado and Texas. And both the Santa Fe locations are well-rated by customers.

There are plenty of different pizzas to choose from here that are classic and gourmet, as well as create your own. The original crust is slightly deeper, while the gourmet version is thin and crispy. Everything is nice and fresh, with the dough and sauce made daily on the premises.

As well as pizzas, there’s a wide range of salads and sauces, plus sandwiches, sides, and a few desserts.

Order to dine in or take out. You can also get Dion’s to cater your event, and they’ll deliver your food for free with orders of over $150.

 

7. Andiamo!

• Address: 322 Garfield Street, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
• Tel: 505-995-9595

Andiamo! is a traditional tratorria— an Italian-style eating establishment— with a wide selection of entrees, pasta dishes, and desserts. And it’s also a great place to get an authentic Italian pizza.

The menu changes daily, and all the ingredients are fresh and high quality. The beautiful old villa offers a lovely dine-in place while presenting excellent service. But you can also order your food for delivery or curbside collection.

Note that during the pandemic, it’s closed for lunch. But you can check the website for up-to-date information on opening times and to reserve a table.

 

8. Bruno’s Pizzeria

• Address: 1512 Paseo De Peralta, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
• Tel: 505-690-0966

Bruno’s is a beloved Santa Fe institution with a family tradition of making pizza for over five generations. So if you’re looking for a pie and something sweet, this is a great option!

Pizzas are available by the pie and the slice, in sizes from 8 to 20 inches. There’s even a pizza slider menu for those who’d prefer to take a sample of different flavors. You can order a 16-inch pizza with various toppings for each quarter. Aside from this, you can get a flatbread pizza the same way too.

All the pizzas undergo the baking process in an authentic wood-fired pizza oven. Plus, there’s a wide range of toppings you can choose from.

There’s also a small but good selection of salads. And for afters, there’s gelato, cannoli, and a refreshing limoncello granita.

 

9. Lino’s Trattoria and Pizzeria

• Address: 204 North Guadalupe Street, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501
• Tel: 505-982-8474

From six days a week, Lino’s is now open daily to serve their loyal customers. You can order online or in person for delivery or curbside pickup. You can also make a reservation for dine-in to experience their unique atmosphere.

The pizzeria offers an excellent choice of flavor combinations. Vegans will also love the range of options, including the VIP – Vegan Impossible Pizza. And if you fancy pasta instead, we’d recommend the Frank Sinatra – fettuccine with mushrooms, shallots, green peas, and a delicious rosemary cream sauce.

Lastly, let us remind you that this isn’t the cheapest place to eat. But all the buck spent equates to their top-notch service and quality foods.

 

10. Joe’s Dining

• Address: 2801 Rodeo Road, A-5 in Rodeo Plaza, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87507
• Tel: 505-471-3800

Joe’s menu goes far beyond pizza. Here you can enjoy everything from burgers to sandwiches, pasta to entrees, salads to appetizers. There’s even an extensive breakfast menu.

But while the pizzas may not be the only game in town, they’re well worth checking out.

Here, the simple Margherita is elevated to an art form. Like all Joe’s pizzas, it’s breaming with Joe’s own mozzarella, made several times a day. You won’t find fresher. And it’s offered only in the late summer and early autumn when the ideal quality of New Mexico heirloom tomatoes are available.

Give it a try, and taste the difference. You can also buy a range of other classic and innovative pizzas. All are available in 10 and 16-inch diameters, enough for six and twelve slices, respectively.

11. Pizzeria Espiritu

• Address: 1722 Saint Michaels Drive, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505-5443
• Tel: 505-424-8000

Pizzeria Espiritu offers pizzas, salads, pasta, sandwiches, and desserts. You can dine in or order for curbside pickup. And finally, a delivery option via Doordash only on weekdays. You can also check their website for the updated time slot since they close between lunch and dinner.

Pizzas are available in four different diameters, from personal to party sizes pies. Vegetarians are also well catered for, with six out of nine specialty pizzas being meat-free. There’s also an extensive list of toppings to create your thin crust, pan, or calzone.

Desserts here are particularly tempting. You can choose Italian classics like tiramisu and other specialties like cheesecake, chocolate mousse cake, and a gigantic chocolate chip cookie.

 

12. Pizza Etc.

• Address: 552 N Guadalupe St, Santa Fe, NM 87501
• Tel: 505-986-1500

Pizza Etc. has been serving great pizzas made with local organic flour since 1995. Today it caters to pizza lovers of all tastes, with meaty, vegan, and gluten-free options on the menu.

Plain cheese, pepperoni, and many more are available by the slice. But you can also order four different crust sizes. And there’s a choice of gluten-free crusts with three diameters available.

There’s a good range of toppings to create your pizza. And other seasonal specialties like the Fiesta Pizza, featuring fajita beef and roasted, locally grown green chilies. Calzones and Stromboli are available too. And all the dough is made fresh daily.

 

13. Tender Fire

• Address: El Rey Court, 1862 Cerillos Road, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
• Tel: 413-374-9191

If you’re the kind of person who likes to plan, Tender Fire could be the perfect pizzeria for you. It publishes its new weekly menu every Tuesday, with pre-order slots for the following week. Book early – they’ve usually sold out by Wednesday night.

Pre-ordering can be done online. Check out the website for details. There’s also some limited availability for walk-up orders, so your best bet is to check around 8:30 pm. You’ll need to do it in person, though. The small staff will focus on food preparation, so they won’t be able to answer the phone or check texts.

Order in advance and your pizza will be put into the outdoor brick oven when you check in. It will be ready between 5 and 15 minutes. But if you’ve ordered five or more pizzas, expect it to take longer to get served.

Many of the pizzas here are vegetarian and vegan. Whatever the ingredients, the emphasis is on sustainability, with produce sourced as close to home as possible.

 

14. Papa Murphy’s

• Address: 3005 South Saint Francis Drive, Santa Fe, NM 87505
• Tel: 505-984-0099

If you want the convenience of carryout with the fresh-out-of-the-oven taste of home baking, Papa Murphy’s could be for you. The take ’n’ bake chain assembles your pizza to order, ready for you to bake at home.

The Santa Fe branch gets good reviews from locals. There’s a great range of pizzas, including keto-friendly “pizza bowls” – all the ingredients without the crust. There are various options for meat-eaters and vegetarians, and sides and salads are available too.

You can either collect your pizza at the store or get it delivered via GrubHub, Uber Eats, or Postmates.

 

15. Piccolino

• Address: 2890 Agua Fria Street, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87507
• Tel: 505-471-1480

The family-owned Piccolino’s sits on the corner of Agua Fria and Siler. The menu here is vast with a good range of pizzas alongside appetizers and sides. That includes calzones, salads, and many more! And don’t worry since they also have a kid’s menu for the little ones.

You can order to dine in the cheerful restaurant with its checkered tablecloths or collect your food curbside. Service can sometimes be a little slow, so this isn’t the place to go if you’re in a hurry. But the food is simple and good quality.

 

16. Hawt Pizza Co.

• Address: 125 Washington Ave, Santa Fe, NM 87501
• Tel: 505-216-1066

Hawt comes from the phrase “Have A Wonderful Time”. It represents the joy the customers experience after having their pizza. Plus, it sounds Hot, symbolizing the burning temperature where they cook their pies. And if you’re curious about how hot it is, it reaches about 850 degrees Fahrenheit.

So the first thing you’ll notice is the charred sides but don’t worry! It’s not burned—instead, it is smoky and caramelized to perfection. And if you’re not a fan of those, you can ask them to fire your pizza light.

Also, don’t forget to check their next-level extras. We’re sure you don’t want to miss the everything spice crust and center ball of Buratta!

17. Pranzo Italian Grill

• Address: 321 Johnson St, Santa Fe, NM 87501
• Tel:505-984-2645

Pranzo operated in 1987 and continued serving the community of Santa Fe. Plus, all the tourists from around the world. It is a casual fine dining restaurant that is local-centric and family oriented. They have antipasti like charcuterie, shishito peppers, and other light yet savory dishes.

Aside from this, they also offer eight kinds of pizza. That includes Margherita and sausage-filled for the kids at heart. But we recommend you try the pig and pear for a unique flavor combination.

Time For Pizza!

We hope you’ve enjoyed our tour of 17 places to get the best pizza in Santa Fe! There are lots on offer in New Mexico, whether you want to dine in or prefer to eat at home. Plus, there’s a pizzeria to suit all budgets.

So next time you want a pizza, why not try somewhere new? We hope you enjoy your meal!